Body Candy Monthly Club

What's in the box: The site does not state exact box contents, but it likely draws on the store's piercing jewelry catalog, such as nose, ear or belly pieces.

Body Candy is best known as an online shop for body piercing jewelry, and its storefront is built around that: nose rings, belly rings, nipple rings, septum, tragus, helix, daith, rook, conch, plugs and more, plus 14k gold pieces, personalized items and aftercare products. A Membership link sits in the main menu, but the site does not clearly spell out what the monthly club ships, how often, or what it costs, so read the membership terms carefully before signing up. Know this up front: although it is sometimes grouped with temporary tattoo and body art boxes, the store's focus is real piercing jewelry, not stick on tattoos. If temporary tattoos are what you want, look elsewhere. On the plus side, the catalog is large, and many listings name implant grade titanium, 14k gold filled or 925 sterling silver, which matters for anyone with sensitive or healing piercings. Popular items show strong ratings from a good number of customers, which points to an established shop with steady buyers. The catch is that a subscription only makes sense if you swap jewelry often and are happy receiving pieces you did not pick, in gauges and styles that may not suit your piercings. Check whether you can set preferences for gauge, metal and placement, and confirm how to pause or cancel.